Images tower · floor

How to remove background in GIMP: three tools, one setting

There is a step before the selection that decides whether any of this works, and it is easy to skip because nothing prompts you for it. It takes one menu item, and you can tell whether you need it by looking at a layer name.

With that done, the question becomes which selection tool. GIMP ships several and they are not interchangeable — the manual distinguishes them precisely, in one sentence that decides which to reach for.

The difference between the first two is worth stating again slowly, because it decides which one to reach for. Fuzzy Select follows connection. It spreads out from where you clicked into whatever is joined to it. Select by Color ignores connection entirely and takes every pixel of a similar colour anywhere in the image. A sky broken up by branches is a Select by Color job; a single continuous backdrop is a Fuzzy Select one.

And now the sentence that makes GIMP’s manual worth reading rather than summarising.

Two useful things follow from that. First, if you have tried this before and found it maddening, the manual agrees with you — it is not a sign of doing it wrong. Second, the named cause is the starting point rather than the settings, so when a fuzzy selection goes strange, the first thing to change is where you clicked.

For anything a colour rule cannot separate — hair against a busy scene, an object that shares its tones with what is behind it — the manual points at a different tool, and this one has a procedure worth following exactly.

Step three is worth naming carefully, because the screen changes into something that does not look like an edit: you are not editing the picture yet. You are telling the tool which parts of your rough outline were the subject, by painting on them. The tool options give you the other direction too — the manual lists Draw foreground, Draw background and Draw unknown, so a mistake is corrected by switching mode and painting over it rather than by starting again.

A warning GIMP puts on its own tool. “The foreground select tool needs a lot of memory for its processing, depending on the size of the image. It is known to crash or slow down.” The manual offers a trade rather than a fix: speed improves by increasing the number of downsampled steps, but “these options also come with the disadvantage of being less accurate.” So on a large photograph the realistic choices are patience, a smaller copy, or a worse edge — and knowing that in advance is better than discovering it halfway through an outline.

One small practical note from the same page, in case you go looking for a shortcut: there isn’t one. “This tool has no shortcut, but you can set one using Edit → Keyboard Shortcuts” — so if you are going to do this often, that is where to add it.

And if the tool options are not visible at all, the manual gives the route: Windows → Dockable Windows → Tool Options. They normally appear under the toolbox as soon as a tool is active, but a rearranged workspace can hide them, and every setting mentioned above lives there.

What this page will not do is tell you which result is good enough. Edge quality on a cut-out is a judgement, and it depends on where the picture is going — a thumbnail forgives what a full-width header will not. The manual documents the tools; it does not, and cannot, set your standard.

The floors below take it three ways: the setting that has to come first, the three tools and when each one fits, and the neighbouring jobs on the same image.

What this tower will not do

It will not send you to an upload site. The job described here is done by a free program on your own machine, and a background removal that never leaves the computer is a different proposition from one that does.

It will not pretend the easy tool is always enough. GIMP’s own manual says users grow frustrated with Fuzzy Select, and a page that left that out would be setting you up for it.

And it will not tell you the result is good. Edge quality is a judgement about where the image is going, and the manual documents tools rather than standards. What holds instead is simple: the note that layers without an alpha channel are shown in bold and the menu route to add one, the definitions of Fuzzy Select and Select by Color and the difference between them, the manual’s remarks about starting points and about growing frustration, the Foreground Select procedure with its yellow closing dot, Enter, two-tone preview and continuous line, the Draw foreground, background and unknown options, the memory and accuracy warning, and the absence of a keyboard shortcut are quoted from the official GIMP documentation, listed below.